Now that we know Andy’s story and Alicia’s story, what is your reaction?  Lessons about relationships?

Comment by April 1.

This is an intense book–Crutcher tackles some tough issues right from the get-to and has faced plenty of static.  What strikes you so far about the novel?

Please comment by March 23

Final thoughts on the book? The ending? Which characters are the most in denial?

The town of Steepleton has much in common with Stanberry, along with some differences.  How well can you relate to the setting and the characters? Torey is distancing himself more and more from his “perfect life”.  Can he turn back now? Should he?

Please comment by February 8.

We’ve just found out why Melinda’s friends (and other students) are mad at her.  Is there anything worse than being an outcast? What do you think of Melinda’s ways of coping with her situation?  How does her family life add to or detract from her situation?

What are your final thoughts about the novel?  You’ve done some research on domestic violence for your projects–what info have you found surprising or noteworthy?

Now that we’re about halfway through Breathing Underwater, have your impressions of Nick or any of the other characters changed since the beginning of the novel?  What do you think about Leo’s story? How effective is the anger management class for the various members? Other comments so far?